Reliable (1880)
Scroll Down
By The Numbers
Lives Lost
Depth (ft)
Service History

The Reliable was originally built as a scow schooner in 1880. For most of her life, Detroit was her home port, but in 1910 she was moved to Lake Michigan and used as a sandsucker. She had been rebuilt a few times and in 1890 a steam power plant was added so she could become a sandsucker sucking sand from the lake bottom for commercial use.
Final Voyage

"The Reliable ... was what was known as a sandsucker... and had been plying between here and South Milwaukee for sand for several years. Saturday morning the usual trip was made and at 2:30 in the afternoon the boat was almost loaded when the storm came up. Not wishing to take the risk of beaching the boat, Capt. Krumer started north about two miles from the shoreline. When a mile or two from South Milwaukee, a leak was discovered in the hold. The crew was set at it and pumped for two hours before Capt. Krumer decided that it would be necessary to lighten the boat by getting rid of some of the cargo. Then the crew turned its efforts to dumping sand overboard. At about 6 o'clock the Chicago bound for Milwaukee and passed the Reliable a few hundred yards out... Five minutes later...(Capt. McGarity) ... heard the whistles of the Reliable calling for help. The Chicago immediately put about. As the Goodrich steamer neared the scene the crew of the sinking vessel was seen putting off in the lifeboat..." "The crew, Capt. Krumer, and his two sons were saved by the steamer Chicago as the Reliable started to list and her boilers blew. Capt. Krumer stayed on board the Reliable even as she was sinking, but was rescued from the water from the water after the explosion."

Despite her well-known foundering point and close proximity to Milwaukee Harbor, the Reliable's remains have never been found. She has been the subject of a number of searches, but her resting place continues to remain a mystery.

Possibly found by Jerry Guyer just east of the break wall between the main gap and south gap.
Confirmed Location     Unconfirmed location
Shipwrecks (85)
A.B.C.F.M. (American Baptist Council Foreign Mission) (1854)
A.W. Lawrence (1881)
Adell (1860)
Algomah (1861)
Alice E. Wilds (1883)
Alleghany (1849)
Appomattox (1896)
Ashtabula (1854)
Badger (1837)
Barbarian (1855)
View 75 more
Shipwrecks (85)
A.B.C.F.M. (American Baptist Council Foreign Mission) (1854)
A.W. Lawrence (1881)
Adell (1860)
Algomah (1861)
Alice E. Wilds (1883)
Alleghany (1849)
Appomattox (1896)
Ashtabula (1854)
Badger (1837)
Barbarian (1855)
Black Hawk
Boston (1846)
Buckeye State (1852)
Buena Vista (1847)
C.C. Trowbridge (1838)
Cape Horn (1857)
Contest (1863)
Cumberland (1847)
E.M.B.A. (Employes' Mutual Benefit Association) (1890)
Edward E. Gillen (1872)
Edward E. Gillen (1908)
Elbe (1853)
Emily A. Roelofson (1854)
Evergreen (1864)
Fearless (1893)
Fitz Simons & Connell Dredge #6 (1912)
Freddie (1901)
Free Mason (1854)
George W. Westcott (1863)
Golden (1892)
Grace Grummond (1869)
Grayling (1876)
H. Marsh (1838)
Hiram R. Bond (1888)
Honest John (1849)
Hunter (1855)
Hurrah Boys (1872)
Ida H. Lee (1863)
J. Steinhart (1853)
J.P. Decoudres (1873)
John D. Dewar (1885)
John F. Porter (1840)
John V. Jones (1875)
Josephine (1874)
Kearsarge (1864)
Kenosha (1919)
Knight Templar (1890)
L.W. Perry (1870)
Laurina (1875)
Lavinda (1863)
Leo (1886)
Liberty (1835)
Lightship 57 (1891)
Lily E. (1869)
M.H. Stuart (1921)
M.J. Cummings (1874)
Maine (1852)
May Queen (1853)
Mayflower JR.(1913)
Milwaukee Fire Boat #17 (1893)
Milwaukee Fire Boat #23 (1896)
Nebraska (1849)
Nile (1843)
Norlond (1890)
Orleans (1846)
Prins Willem V (1948)
Progress (1880)
Rough Ready (1885)
Sailor Boy (1866)
Sea Serpent (1821)
Sebastopol (1855)
Sioux (1883)
Snow Drop (1853)
Solomon Juneau (1837)
Starke (1889)
Storm King (1856)
Sumatra (1874)
Tanner (1863)
Tempest (1854)
Thomas A. Scott (1869)
Toboggan (1886)
Transfer (1872)
Twin Brothers (1848)
Volunteer (1888)
William McGregor
View fewer
© 2019 - Wisconsin Sea Grant, Wisconsin Historical Society