"The three-masted schooner James Garrett
was blown ashore on the morning of 5/30/1889, in Whitefish Bay. According to the Door County Advocate of 6/15/1889, "...when the vessel approached the pier in Whitefish Bay (on 5/29/1880) Capt. Smith let go the anchor and payed out the cable, this being done in order to heave the schooner away from the pier in case of bad weather. Owing to an error in Capt. Smith's estimate of the distance, the anchor was dropped too soon, and the cable not being long enough to reach the pier a piece of hawser was made fast to it and carried on board. Had Capt. Smith picked up the anchor and brought it in shore far enough to let the chain reach the vessel there would have been no trouble. When the northeaster set in, instead of pulling away from the pier, which could have easily been done, the captain and all hands turned in for the night. The storm increased in violence until nine o'clock the following morning, when the tow post gave way, and then an effort was made to haul the schooner out to her anchor, but the hawser previously mentioned parted, and she went on the beach."
"During the storm of three weeks ago a part of the wreck of the old schooner James Garrett
was loosened and carried along the south side of the pier at Whitefish Bay where it remained for some little time. The heavy northeaster of last week carried the wreckage out into the lake, and that is the last seen of it."
Final Enrollment "Abandoned June 12, 1889"